When Holden arrived at his home, he felt sense of security. Pete who was regular night elevator bot was not on the car. Some new guy he had never seen was on the car. Holden was pleased, because he thought that he could meet Phoebe easily. Holden told new elevator guy to take him up to the Dicksteins’ floor. The Dicksteins were other apartment on his floor. Holden deceive elevator guy that he was nephew of Dicksteins. When he got off at his floor, he went to his house, and opened the door. He entered his house very quietly. Although his father and maid did not hear well, his mother heard very well. When Holden opened the Phoebe’s room, he was not in his room, because he was in D.B’s room. So he went to D.B’s room, and he met Phoebe. As soon as Holden woke up Phoebe, he woke up fast. They talked to the play that she was in first and they talked a lot of things then Holden got out of D.B’s room. They talked a lot of things such as play and D.B, and Phoebe knew Holden was failed, so Phoebe worried Holden. In this chapter Holden’s action was always so cautious, because he did not know when he was caught by his parents. When he met Phoebe, he felt gladness and happiness.Holden returned to D.B’S room and began to talk with Phoebe. Phoebe resented Holden, so Holden tried to soothe Phoebe. He talked about his Pency school’s story. Holden said Robert Burns’s poem to Phoebe. Holden wanted to be catcher in the rye. Holden also mentioned Spencer. At the end of chapter, Holden call to Mr.Antolini. Maybe, Holden and Phoebe will bring reconciliation.
Questions for commentators:
What is the name of Phoebe’s play and Phoebe’s role?
Why Holden wanted to be catcher in the rye?
If you were Holden and Phoebe knew Holden was fail, how did you talk to Phoebe?
Other Groups:
Group 1: Philosopher
Group 2: Commentator
Group 3: Heckler
Group 4: Commentator
1. She served as Benedict Arnold.
ReplyDelete2. The children who are running blindly without knowing the destination, so Holden want to hold this children.
3. I will want to drop out of school myself.
1.is her part is important?? what is the first scene of her part.
Delete2.why Holden want to hold them??
3.Phoebe do not cry..
1. Why she served as Benedict Arnold?
Delete2. Why Holden wanted to catch the children who are running blindly with out knowing the destination?
3. There are many different solution, but why you will drop out of school yourself?
1.She's role was Benedict Arnold
ReplyDelete2.Holden wants to protect children from dirty society
3.I can not stand in school anymore so I quit school by myself
1. Is this important role in this play? How she think her role?
Delete2. Why holden think our society is dirty?
3. Oh, that's too bad hearing, how about find different things?
1.She take a role Benedict Arnold. 2.Holden wants children didn't know about the dirty society.and Holden wants to protect children. 3.Because I didn'like school.
ReplyDelete1.Why she chose that part in the play? Is it common point between real and play?
Delete2. I think he want to be a catcher in the rye but also he need catcher in the rye for control him.
3. Your job is student. We have to keep study. I recommend that you find out another solution
1.Does she wants to take a role Benedict Armold?
Delete2.I don't know dirty society which is bad.
3.your answer are not good at young children.
1.She has Benedict Arnold role for the play
ReplyDelete2.Holden wants prevent the children from society
3. Frankly, This school is not my type for example, some teacher and curricular
1.Does Phoebe like that?
Delete2. Why Holden want to prevent children from that?
3. Think about Phoebe's answer.
1. She play a role of Benedict Arnol.
ReplyDelete2. Holden didn't want to children exposure to dirty society.
3. Because I dislike school
1. Phoebe's role is Benedict arnol, and she think that it is very important role in the play.
ReplyDelete2. Holden wants to protect Phobe from society.
3. I have a plan, so don't worry about that.
1. She's role name is Benedict Arnol.
ReplyDelete2. Holden wants to protect his sister from dirty society.
3. I can't go school anymore,so I hope at least you are studying hard